Blog

Resolving the Collision Between Legal Holds and Data Privacy

Discover how modern legal departments can proactively resolve conflicts between legal holds and data privacy through upstream governance and data mapping.

For years, eDiscovery professionals focused primarily on the right side of the Electronic Discovery Reference Model (EDRM)—collecting, processing, reviewing, and producing data once litigation was already underway–while the work on the left hand side of the EDRM, including issuing and managing legal holds and pre-collection data assessment, were largely routine tasks. 

Today, rising data volumes, tightening corporate budgets, and an expanding patchwork of privacy regulations have made that reactive approach unsustainable. Modern legal departments must shift their focus upstream, treating eDiscovery as a proactive funnel that begins with disciplined information governance, long before a lawsuit hits.

On a recent episode of the Data Xposure podcast, Nick Curtis, eDiscovery Manager at Tokio Marine, shared how enterprise legal teams can master the left side of the funnel–and thereby achieve real business results for their organization. Drawing on experience from both the legal service provider world and in-house corporate operations, Nick outlines how to untangle conflicting compliance mandates, prioritize global data risks, and build upstream visibility across the enterprise.

Listen to the full conversation with Nick Curtis on Data Xposure here.

When Legal Holds Collide with Data Privacy

In an enterprise environment, data rarely belongs to a single regulatory regime. One of the sharpest operational friction points occurs when an active litigation hold lands on records that are simultaneously governed by a corporate retention schedule or a consumer privacy request.

"You can have data on a legal hold that's also subject to a data subject request. If someone submits and says, 'We want destruction of our private data,'" Nick explains. "But some of that data may exist and need to be preserved for a legal hold. So now you have competing obligations, and that situation is resolved doing an observation on which obligation takes precedence."

In practice, legal preservation duties for active litigation generally override routine deletion requests—but spotting that conflict before data is inadvertently wiped requires intentional coordination. Whether a team catches those crossed wires upfront or mid-process depends directly on the maturity of its governance framework and how closely legal communicates with data privacy, information governance, and IT security teams.

A Four-Tier Framework for Data Risk

When evaluating corporate data, Nick examines four core dimensions: where the data lives, how it is secured, what privacy obligations apply, and which cross-border transfer rules govern it. Among those four, privacy obligations and cross-border requirements consistently create the steepest operational hurdles.

"There's different privacy laws in different states and those get updated, but people are barely made aware of the various updates. There's really no kind of notification that is delivered. So that's kind of the hardest thing," Nick notes. 

Rather than jumping straight into collection tools, Nick ranks corporate data priorities in a strict sequence from foundational compliance down to tactical execution:

  1. Cross-Border Requirements and Data Privacy Obligations: Understanding jurisdictional restrictions and constantly evolving state and international privacy mandates before touching the data.
  2. Security Concerns: Ensuring sensitive enterprise information remains protected throughout its lifecycle.
  3. Information Governance: Mapping where data actually resides and how it flows across the organization.
  4. Collection and Preservation: Executing defensible legal holds and targeted collections once the regulatory bedrock is clear.

How Clean Data Governance Saves Real Money

Because in-house legal departments operate as cost centers rather than revenue generators, poor upstream governance carries an immediate financial penalty. When companies fail to map their data or govern it consistently, they risk hiring the wrong forensic vendor, collecting overbroad datasets, or paying twice to redo botched work.

During his time on the service provider side, Nick could immediately gauge a corporate legal department’s maturity just by looking at how it handed over files:

"Usually if it's structured, neat, and properly [delivered], usually that's an indication of good information governance and good identification and collection of data," Nick says. "You can get hints through communication and through also how the data is provided to you on whether or not a company has a good hold on how they recognize data and how they govern the data."

At Tokio Marine, Nick operationalizes this upstream visibility by focusing on the left side of the EDRM through integrated tooling in Exterro—specifically pairing HR mapping with automated data source discovery.

"The data source discovery allows us to go in and look at the different data sources, particularly the most popular ones that we collect from—Exchange and OneDrive and network file shares, the personal shares—those have been huge for us," Nick shares. "That kind of works hand in hand with the HR mapping, which populates with the employee information... That piece of it is kind of big because it's more focused on the left side of the e-discovery reference model."

By pre-populating custodian details and automatically indexing primary repositories, legal teams eliminate guesswork, shrink collection scopes early, and reduce downstream review costs.

Breaking Out of the Legal Silo

Technology can map repositories and automate hold notices, but upstream readiness ultimately depends on cross-functional alignment. Corporate data is managed across HR, IT security, privacy, and business units—meaning an eDiscovery team working in isolation cannot build a defensible program.

Resolving conflicts between privacy rights and litigation readiness requires ongoing dialogue across those departments before urgent matters arise. When legal operations pair clear governance rules with proactive cross-departmental communication, they transform eDiscovery from an expensive, reactive scramble into a predictable, defensible business process.

Want to learn more about building proactive information governance and streamlining corporate legal workflows?

Tune in to this conversation with Nick Curtis on Data Xposure to hear his firsthand insights on navigating privacy conflicts, cross-border rules, and upstream eDiscovery strategy.

To learn more about how Exterro helped Tokio Marine update its eDiscovery process, check out the case study here.